My birthday is Halloween... so when I saw this place we had to try it out. For being a themed restaurant the food was very good. Our waiter was great. He was super attentive and never missed a beat! The burger was fresh, the apps were tasty. For sure worth a try if you are in the area.

Yelp reminded me to review this place when I logged in. We took my 7 year old here for her birthday. We figured she LOVES a good burger, she loves halloween and figured it would be a fun adventure. The food was quite good. The decore was pretty cool, but it took my daughters a while to get comfortable, they were a little freaked out for a good portion of the visit. They did finally warm up and had fun, but it may not be everyone's cup of tea. It is noisy and the staff was mediocre. Not super responsive and because of the noise, hard to communicate with. I'd recommend it as a one time thing, but go in prepared for a lot of chaos.

The staff and the food were wonderful The waiter we had was extremely friendly. We love the decor. Everything we ordered on the menu was delicious. No complaints whatsoever. The drinks were exceptional! We Will be coming back again

I discovered the Haunted House of Hamburgers last year on Random Google search and then forgot all about it because I do not traverse to upper LI very often. Luckily!! I had plans in Bethpage and this was 6 minutes away! If you have not been here yet or if you are just finding out about it right NOW I suggest you make it a point to check this place out. Super kid friendly FYI!! I made my reservations thru Yelp for the same day, which was seamless. Outside decor and vibe is awesome. We went on a cloudy day which just added to the whole experience. Adult beverages made to order off the menu - spooky delights ! The food menu is quite extensive and we both got burgers (because Haunted House of Hamburgers) right? I was so full i couldn't finish mine which was regretful because it was very yummy. Staff was attentive and kind. I'm curious if they have extra staff at Halloween time, I really feel like interactive costumed staff would be a great hit if that's the case. I will return to find out !!

Looks like a big place from the outside. Very small in side but worth it. If you like Halloween stuff you gotta stop by. Huge menu of drinks appetizers and main course meals. I ordered the scared bless bbq wings. Awesome. Juicy & fresh along with the monster Macaroni & cheeseburger. Came with fries. I'm telling you this is probably the best burger I had in a long time. Has a full bar if that's your kind of thing. Service was great. It was about a 90 min drive for me one way but well worth it. I'm told it gets busy at night so make sure you make a reservation. Lunch I just walked in. Really neat .... Be back soon... oh forgot the burger buns with embossed toasted with name of establishment which thought was neat.... @yelpnewjersey